Classic Banoffee Pie

One of the most searched-for recipes that leads people to Happiness Stan is ‘banana-less banoffee pie’. If you took a look at the link you can see this is not really anything to do with banoffee pie, I just like playing with words and peoples’ heads (and taste buds).

But who would look for such a thing as banana-less banoffee pie? What kind of tortured soul is even thinking about, let alone seriously considering, such a thing? Maybe they are distant relatives of the Spanish Conquistadors, who’s search for the Lost City of Gold ended as fruitlessly as their modern descendants looking for a recipe that cannot exist. Mind you the conquistadors may well have tripped over some bananas as they explored the virgin rainforests desperate for a first glimpse of Eldorado.

More likely they are conflicted. On the one hand the thought of cream, biscuit, caramel and chocolate seems like a no-brainer. However countering this is the thought of sticking bits of slimy, pale yellow fruit into an otherwise perfect creation.


This is the Eldorado of Banoffee Pies

Conflicted indeed. But only if you have an aversion to banana. Personally I see, smell and taste nothing wrong with bananas. Take ‘em or leave ‘em. Not bothered.

But you do need them if you want to make ‘real’ Banoffee Pie. In fact you need:


  • 200g melted butter (half for the biscuit base and half for the chocolate ganache)
  • 250g digestive biscuits (half a big pack. For those not familiar with these biscuits I have read about saltine crackers but I’m not sure; I mean you don’t want to be using salty crackers)
  • 1 tin Nestle caramel topping (it’s Dulce de Leche, see note below about this)
  • 1 bar dark chocolate
  • 1 bar white chocolate
  • 3 bananas
  • ½ pint double (heavy) cream
  • 1 ½ tsp vanilla paste or essence
  • 2 tbsp icing (confectioner’s) sugar
  • Cocoa powder (about ½ tbsp)

Already some might note this recipe is not a classic banoffee pie. Why? Because I have stuck a load of chocolate ganache in it which isn’t strictly speaking correct. But you’re unwitting tasters won’t care a bit.

First whizz the biscuits in a processor until powdery. This may take longer than you would think.


The oldest took control of this creation

Then add half the melted butter and continue to whizz until well combined. Don’t think too much about what you are doing; you’re adding a load of butter to biscuits that already contain loads of butter. But this isn’t optional people. If you don’t your biscuit base will have the consistency of edible sand!


Press the biscuit base into a lined springform tin (around 23cm in diameter) and pop in the fridge for half an hour to chill.


Spoon the caramel over the biscuit base. Nestle Caramel is just a shortcut to making your own caramel. You can make it from scratch (with sugar, cream and butter) or you can heat up a tin of carnation milk in a pan of water. Or you can just get it out of a tin like I do.


Return to the fridge and make the ganache. Break all of the chocolate into a glass bowl, leaving three pieces to the side for grating on to the finished pie.


Melt over a pan of slightly simmering water until melted. Remove from the heat and stir in the remaining melted butter.


Slice the bananas the arrange over the caramel layer.


Pour the ganache over the bananas and leave in the fridge to set and chill.


Finally the cream. Pour into a large metal bowl and begin whisking with an electric whisk. Add the vanilla essence and sift in the icing sugar.


Continue to whisk until you get ‘soft peaks’. Be careful not to whisk too much or you end up with stiff cream that will be more like sweet soft cheese than the foamy slightly sloppy cream you want.

Dollop spoonfuls of cream onto the pie. Finish with cocoa powder and grated chocolate.


Now this bad boy did the rounds at both my parent’s house and the in-laws.


I was slightly disappointed with the sloppy consistency of the caramel layer. My father-in-law commented that this can be addressed by warming the caramel in a pan. I believe him as he used to work at Mars, and rumour has it that he invented the Crunchie sweet in the Celebrations selection. I do not know whether this is fact or myth but I like to think it is true!


And before anyone wittily asks how the diet is going I did not eat this badboy. Might have scooped a bit off the Mrs’ plate but that doesn’t count.


21 thoughts on “Classic Banoffee Pie

  1. You made THIS and you didn’t eat it??? Incredible!
    I love banoffee pie, and bring on the bananas – yum yum. I also love the look of your banana-less one, but then anything with chocolate and a biscuit base is a winner in my book. I’m only surprised you held back on the whipped cream topping with that one 😉

  2. I’ve never had a banoffee pie before, and I must say, it looks like the kind of thing I need to try at least once. It seems to me that one slice of that might provide satisfaction for a very long time! Yours is my favourite health food blog 😊

    • Good question. Does seem a bit counter intuitive. Maybe it’s something to do with the fat content of milk chocolate, not sure whether white chocolate may actually have less. But then I wouldn’t know whether that makes any difference. Also, now I think about it, mixing white and dark seems to keep the overall mix looking like dark, but the ganache is softer. I could go on….!

    • Strange I thought it was an American creation like Mud Pie. Then I looked it up and founf it was created in an English restaurant in the 70s when they ran out of their regular offering

  3. You could have put anything in this and I’d still me nodding, saying…yup, that looks good, oh yeah, need to try this. I’ve seriously ever heard of Banofee pie but I’m sold on this creation. Interesting about the caramel and I’m with you on trusting someone who worked at Mars.
    Funny the things people search for though – my biggest is What to pack when you’re running away from home”! You have no idea of how many young kids I’ve emailed back to talk out of doing that.

  4. Your willpower is admirable! Looks so good. I use a recipe with cream cheese mixed with the caramel, which is almost as decadent as adding all that chocolate. 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s